Sold Homes in Bay Shore NY 11706

There were 39 sold homes in Bay Shore during February 2020.  Of the 39 sold homes, 20 are in Bay Shore School District, 14 are in Brentwood School District, 2 are in Islip School District and 3 are in West Islip School District.   There were 9 foreclosed sold homes, 5 of which are in Bay Shore School District, 3 are in Brentwood School District and 1 in West Islip School District.  There was 1 home that was a short sale in Brentwood School District.

15 Post Lane, Bay Shore, New York is a 4 bedroom, 3 1/2 bath ranch style house in the Islip School District.  This was the highest sold home in Bayshore during February 2020.  This waterfront property had an original list price of $1,500,000.  It remained on the market for 199 days and sold for $1,288,888.  Total taxes are $33,611.

Compared to February 2019 there were 34 sold homes in Bay Shore.  This included 5 foreclosed homes and 3 short sale homes.

The highest home sold during that period was 882 Manor Lane, a 6 bedroom 3 1/2 bath farm ranch in the Bay Shore School District.  This house had an original list price of $879,000.  It was on the market for 127 days and sold for $790,000.  Taxes at the time was $20,553.90.

In February 2018, there were 33 sold homes, the highest of which was, 22 S Penataquit Ave,  Bay Shore,  NY 11706.  This 6 bedroom, 3 bath colonial was listed for $799,000 and sold in 10 days for 780,000.  In the Bay Shore School District, the taxes at that time was $18,928.58.  There were 8 foreclosed sold homes.

About Carlene Calabrese


  • Buyer Representation
  • Certified Buyer Representative (CBR®)
  • Seller Representation
  • Premier Listing Agent
  • Probate Home Sales
  • Certified Probate Real Estate Specialist (C.P.R.E.S.)
  • Relocation
  • Investors…-in-babylon-area/…-in-babylon-area/…-in-babylon-area/…-in-babylon-area/…-in-babylon-area/

Connect With Me!

If you're looking to buy or sell a property connect with me today!

How Can I Help You?

I would love to hear from you! Please fill out this form and I will get in touch with you shortly.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *